“The Mysterious Disappearance of Amy Fisher: Unraveling the Truth” –

AN EXTRAMARITAL affair turned deadly when a mistress confronted her lover’s wife and shot her in the head.

Although Mary Jo Buttafuoco survived the violent ordeal, Amy Fisher’s case went to trial, and she was ultimately convicted.

2

What happened to Amy Fisher?

On May 19, 1992, then-17-year-old Amy Fisher arrived at Joey and Mary Jo Buttafuoco’s Massapequa home.

When ‘Long Island Lolita’ Fisher confronted Mary Jo and confessed to having an affair with Joey, Fisher shot Mary Jo in the head.

On May 23 of the same year, Fisher was arrested for the first-degree attempted murder of Mary Jo.

On September 23, 1992, Fisher pleaded guilty to first-degree aggravated assault after she accepted a plea bargain.

“I went up to the doorstep with a loaded gun in my pocket,” Fisher admitted to the court.

“I hit her on the back of the head. I hit her again. The gun went off.”

On December 2 of the same year, she was sentenced to five to 15 years in prison.

She served seven years of her sentence and was incarcerated at Albion Correctional Facility.

In May 1999, Fisher was granted parole and released from prison.

Where is Fisher now?

Fisher now resides in Long Island with her three children from her former marriage to Louis Bellera; they divorced in 2015.

For several years, Fisher worked as a pornographic actress until she retired from the industry in June 2011.

She went on to launch her own adult webcam site where she still regularly performs.

Also a New York Times best-selling author, her first book If I Knew Then was published in 2004.

2

While revisiting her infamous case, Fisher told Oprah Winfrey: “I knew nothing then. What didn’t I learn?

“I learned I should have gone to school and focused on studying instead of men.

“Obviously, [laughing] it’s not nice to shoot people. I’m more self-reflective. I learned to be more compassionate.

“I look back on those dark times and I never thought I’d get to the place I am today. The ‘Long Island Lolita’ is not really who I am.”

The mother-of-three added: “No parent ever wants to think their child could view them as a bad person.

“When the time comes and my son asks me about my past, I’m going to be honest with him.

“All I can do is explain to him that everybody has a past, and all we can do is learn from our mistakes, and be a better person.

“We’ve all done things we’re not proud of but that doesn’t define who we are.”

Why did Mary Jo Buttafuoco forgive Fisher?

In an open letter, Mary Jo Buttafuoco said she forgave Fisher so she could make peace and move forward from her ex-husband’s affair that resulted in the shooting.

Buttafuoco also revealed she was inspired to forgive Fisher after meeting with the assailant’s mother Roseann.

“I have come to the conclusion that Amy Fisher has spent enough time in jail as punishment for her crime,” she wrote.

“It is right and good that I can now say that I forgive Amy Fisher.

“It is a place I have only been able to reach through grace.”

She elaborated to the New York Post: “Amy said to me in her letter that it had nothing to do with me or Joey.

“It had to do with circumstances in her life that were transferred to me…her rage, insecurity, and anger.

“I’ve been waiting seven years to hear that. I broke down like I’ve never broken down before.

“I am a mother. I guess it went to the mother in me. This is a sick girl. This is not a seductress.

“She needed to be punished – she tried to kill me – but Amy Fisher is not a ‘Lolita.’

“I forgive but I’ve always forgiven and I always knew she was sick.”

Buttafuoco sent her forgiveness letter after Fisher offered an apology to the victim.

In her own letter addressed to Buttafuoco, she explained: “I apologize for what I have done.

“I didn’t see you as a human being. I didn’t see you as a mother.

“I pray that you will forgive me and pray that this nightmare will come to an end.”